Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Winkfield Twyman's avatar

I feel like your comments are similar to comments on an earlier essay. Raising issues in good faith doesn't warrant labels. Labels are never arguments, just thought terminating cliches. Why worry about accusations of bullies?

As you know, if there are over 40 million black Americans, there are over 40 million stories, experiences and perspectives. Where the discourse goes wrong is when we drift over into caricatures. For example, you use the term "black community" but what does that term mean? Are people born in Richmond in 1933 in community with young adults born in La Jolla in 2020? Nothing joins the cultural memories of these groups of people. Blackness alone, however defined, doesn't create a black community. So, how does one pander to a fictional creation of the collectivist mind? I think we reinforce stale patterns of problem solving when we accept "black community" as a framing device. Suppose we posed the problem as pandering to individuals who demand x, y and z? Framing the issue though the lens of the individual and human dignity better serves understanding. Just my thought on your second paragraph.

Expand full comment
Dave's avatar

An excellent article. For me to even raise issues related to class or race is to be immediately accused of racism. What the fuck, here goes anyway.

It’s far past time for society to quit pandering to the black community and to demand that it take the lead in correcting the problems that the black underclass faces. Here are a few suggestions. 

There is a systematic lack of respect for education within that community. Tolerance of disruptive students by black school administrators and lack of effective discipline hinders learning in many black majority schools, stifling students’ potential achievement. The simple answer is to expel repeat offenders so that those who desire to learn can learn.

There is a casual acceptance of criminal behavior within many parts of the black community that results in a failure to cooperate with police in solving crimes. Until this is reversed there will be zero economic development within areas where they live.

Finally, someone must find a way to make all black fathers love and care for their children and especially their boy children. Young black men (15-34) are just 2% of the population and commit about half of the nation’s homicides. A rate fifty times higher than the average American. The lack of a father’s involvement in raising their sons is at the heart of this problem yet no one acknowledges it and seeks answers to it. Where the hell are the middle and upper class blacks (and especially black politicians) who even publicly acknowledge this problem?

What are they waiting for?

Expand full comment

No posts